Bad Strategies: How Major Powers Fail in Counterinsurgency by James S. Corum PhD, Dennis Showalter

By James S. Corum PhD, Dennis Showalter

It is the hot method of war:  all over our army attempts to make inroads, insurgents flout us--and appear to get the higher of the strategists making coverage and conflict plans.  during this e-book, a professional with either scholarly and armed forces adventure within the box appears to be like at situations of counterinsurgency long gone wrong.  through studying the mess ups of ideas opposed to insurgents in Algeria, Cyprus,  Vietnam, and Iraq, Lieutenant Colonel James S. Corum bargains infrequent and much-needed perception into what can get it wrong in such situations--and how those blunders can be avoided.  In every one case, Corum indicates how the clash might have been gained by way of the key strength if its technique had addressed the underlying explanations of the insurgency it confronted; no longer doing so wastes lives and weakens the power’s place within the world.

 

Failures in counterinsurgency frequently continue from universal mistakes.  undesirable concepts explores those at strategic, operational and tactical levels.  particularly, Corum identifies terrible civilian and army management because the fundamental reason for failure in effectively battling insurgencies.  His ebook, with transparent and sensible prescriptions for achievement, indicates how the teachings of the previous may perhaps follow to our current disastrous confrontations with insurgents in Iraq.

Show description

Read or Download Bad Strategies: How Major Powers Fail in Counterinsurgency PDF

Best intelligence & espionage books

Key to Sinai, The Battles for Abu Agelia in the - and - Arab Israeli Wars

[Includes five figures and 21 maps]Situated among the Suez Canal and Israel and marked via the cruel atmosphere of the significant Sinai lies Abu Ageila, an unprepossessing sector of low ridges and hills during which passes the best-surfaced highway within the peninsula. due to its situation at the imperative path, as regards to the Israeli-Egyptian border, Abu Ageila turned the most important to the Sinai within the Arab-Israeli wars of 1956 and 1967.

British Commandos

With Hitler's military rampaging throughout Europe, Winston Churchill ordered the production of a unique scuffling with force-- the Commandos. those valiant males have been volunteers drawn from the ranks of the British military, shaped right into a particular provider Brigade, and placed via a rigorous yet powerful education software.

Sniper Rifles: From the 19th to the 21st Century (Osprey Weapon)

A technical define of the historical past of the sniper rifle, from its creation in struggle through the Napoleonic wars, in the course of the US Civil battle to its present apogee because the most often used wrestle rifle in Iraq and Afghanistan. This e-book info the advance of ammunition, diverse guns forms together with unmarried shot, journal loading and semi-automatic, in addition to the advent and use of optical points of interest.

Killer Elite

The “enthralling page-turner” (Library magazine) now a huge movie starring Jason Statham, Clive Owen, and Robert De NiroHere is a gripping novel, encouraged by way of real-life occasions, a few inner most group of British vigilantes that units out to get rid of a gang of cold-blooded agreement killers. From 1977 to 1990, 4 former British infantrymen die, one after the other, supposedly as a result of coincidence or disease.

Additional info for Bad Strategies: How Major Powers Fail in Counterinsurgency

Sample text

From that question one reasons backwards to figure out how to get there, and what kind of problems might be encountered, what resources will be necessary, and so on. ” Absolute victory, à la the surrender on the deck of the Battleship Missouri, is a very rare thing in warfare. When fighting insurgents, governments would like to see the insurgency collapse completely and surrender unconditionally. That is extremely unlikely. In fighting insurgents, most realistic endstates require the government to negotiate a political settlement that makes some concessions to the insurgents.

Regarding Iraq, it appears reasonable to suggest that for the United States, deposing Saddam Hussein was seen as both a means and an end in itself. The insurgents had no common endstate, at least not one strong enough to generate a common front. That, in turn, rendered them potentially susceptible not exactly to “divide and conquer,” but to “divide and convince”—to seek, essentially, a brokered solution balancing mutual dissatisfaction. The jury is still out on the result. Corum’s major specific recommendations to counterinsurgents reinforce the importance of compromise: maintaining a favorable international profile, training local security forces, maintaining public support at home.

There have been cases—Algeria is one—in which the counterinsurgent nation got the military part of the strategy right but then failed to get the other parts of the strategy right. The result was the failure of the whole strategy. One lesson is very consistent; the counterinsurgent nation has to get the civilian and political side of the effort correct, as well as the military side. This means that the government must be able to employ all of its agencies and assets in a coordinated manner. It is not an easy task—but it is also not impossible if the counterinsurgent nation has good leadership directing the effort.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.09 of 5 – based on 28 votes